Mastodon Politics, Power, and Science: Progress Toward What? The Suppressed Reference Frame

Sunday, November 22, 2026

Progress Toward What? The Suppressed Reference Frame

J. Rogers, SE Ohio.

Abstract

"Progress" is treated as a word everyone supports. This paper argues that this is exactly what makes it dangerous in argument. The word carries a direction, a goal, and a valuation, but states none of them. Used as a premise, it ends discussion of goals before the discussion starts. The remedy is a single question, "Progress toward what?", which restores the missing reference frame. I frame the problem as a measurement failure: progress is a velocity quoted with its frame suppressed.

1. The Problem

Nobody argues against progress. That is not evidence that progress is good. It is evidence that the word has been built so that opposition is incoherent. To oppose progress is to be labeled backward, stuck, or afraid.

The word does three things at once:

  1. It asserts that change has a direction.
  2. It asserts that the direction is knowable.
  3. It asserts that the direction is good.

None of these is stated. All of them ride in with the word. A speaker who says "that will kill progress" has made three claims and defended none.

2. The Linguistic Mechanism

Emily Bender identifies the mechanism in a thread on Mastodon (Bender, 2026). Drawing on Fillmore's work on zero anaphora (Fillmore, 1986), she observes that English predicates and nouns can leave arguments unexpressed. Some dropped arguments are recoverable from the discourse ("I told them"). Others are indefinite ("I already ate"). Others carry a default type ("I don't drink" means alcohol).

"Progress" is one of these nouns. "We're making progress" implicitly means progress toward something. In a kitchen, covered in flour, the something is the pies, or Thanksgiving dinner. Common ground fills the slot.

The difficulty appears when the common ground is not shared. Bender's example is a statement of the form "unions kill progress," as glossed by Wendy Liu from Paul Graham (Liu, in conversation with Becker, 2026). Spoken by someone with financial and political power, the missing complement is filled by that speaker's goals: progress toward the hegemonic understanding of what society is for. Bender notes that this goal is not universal health care, universal education, sustainable cities, or reduced inequality.

The key point is hers: because the goal is left unstated and presupposed, and an unchallenged presupposition enters the common ground as accepted, the goal is adopted by default (Bender, 2026).

3. The Retort

Brad Rosenheim states the practical consequence in reply to Bender. When someone says a thing "will kill/hurt/stop/end progress," we generally agree that hindered progress is bad, and the argument stops there. But we never ask toward what. His retort is simple: "Progress toward what?" At that point, he notes, we may find we hold different definitions of progress, and the exchange can continue (Rosenheim, 2026).

This paper takes that question as its subject. It is not rhetorical. It is a request for a value that was withheld.

4. Progress as a Velocity Without a Frame

In physics, a velocity has no meaning until a reference frame is named. "The train is moving at 60 km/h" is incomplete; relative to what? Change is not directional on its own. Direction exists only relative to a chosen reference.

Progress is motion with a sign attached. The sign is the valuation (good), and the vector is the goal. Strip the goal and you have change. Strip the frame and the speaker's frame is installed as the default for everyone. The listener has two options: ride along, or be classified as opposing motion itself.

This is the same failure as a magic number in a system. A value is used everywhere, relied on by everyone, and traceable to no source. Nobody can audit it because nobody can find where it was set. "Progress" is a magic number in public argument. The remedy in both cases is the same: trace the value to its definition and name it.

5. Progress as a Property of the System

A second effect compounds the first. "Unions block progress" treats progress as something with its own momentum, like a river, and the union as an obstruction, like a rock. Grammatically, nobody chose the direction. Progress is simply flowing, and the question of who set its course is erased.

Tiota Sram observes a specific form of this: the answer to "progress toward what?" is often "technological progress, of course," which treats technology as a single monolith that is either advancing or held back (Sram, 2026). This forecloses the possibility of choosing which technologies to develop, or of developing helpful ones without harmful ones. It also supports the related myth that technologies are apolitical. Sram's short story, "The Age of Progress," explores the theme in fiction.

The monolith is the same suppression, one level up. Instead of an unstated goal, there is an unstated category that makes goals unnecessary.

6. A Test and a Practice

The following test identifies the code-word use of "progress":

  • Substitution. Replace "progress" with "change toward [X]" and ask the speaker to fill X. If X cannot be stated, or if stating it makes the claim controversial, the word was doing the work the argument should have done.
  • Frame check. Ask whose goal fills the slot. If the answer is the speaker's, the claim is a preference presented as a neutral fact.
  • Beneficiary check. Ask who gains from the named goal and who bears the cost.

The practice is one question, asked early and without hostility: Progress toward what? It does not oppose progress. It declines to let the word substitute for the goal.

7. Implications

First, disagreement about progress is usually disagreement about goals that has not yet been located. The question moves the argument from a false binary (for or against) to the real one (which direction).

Second, the effect is strongest where the speaker has power, because common ground is set by whoever speaks with authority. Bender's point is that the goal is not merely unstated but presupposed, and presupposition is how an interest becomes a default.

Third, the same structure appears in specialist fields. Where "progress" in a discipline means convergence on the existing framework, the word suppresses the question of whether the framework's own goals and assumptions are the right ones. The frame is invisible because everyone inside it is already moving the same way.

8. Conclusion

"Progress" is not a goal. It is a slot for one. When the slot is left empty and the word is used anyway, the speaker's goal is supplied silently and the discussion of goals never happens. The countermeasure costs three words. Ask what the progress is toward, and name the frame before agreeing to move.

References

Bender, E. M. (2026, November 20). Thread on dropped arguments and the word "progress." Mastodon, @emilymbender@dair-community.social.

Fillmore, C. J. (1986). Pragmatically controlled zero anaphora. Proceedings of the Twelfth Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society.

Liu, W. (2026). Interview, Episode 32: The Tech Labor Movement. Dreaming Against the Machine, hosted by A. Becker. (Paraphrase of a statement by Paul Graham, as glossed by Liu.)

Rosenheim, B. (2026). Reply to Bender, Mastodon, @Brad_Rosenheim@climatejustice.social.

Sram, T. (2026). Reply to Rosenheim and Bender, Mastodon, @tiotasram@kolektiva.social; and "The Age of Progress," cs.wellesley.edu/~pmwh/writing/the_age_of_progress.html.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Project Overview: Mapping the Latent Span Between Physical Theories

J. Rogers, SE Ohio 1. Core Objective: What This Project Is Accomplishing Modern theoretical physics is deadlocked because it treats mutually...