J, Rogers, SE Ohio
In 1974, Francis Ford Coppola directed The Conversation, a tense thriller starring Gene Hackman as Harry Caul, a paranoid surveillance expert haunted by the moral weight of his wiretapping work. Twenty-four years later, director Tony Scott released Enemy of the State (1998), casting Gene Hackman as Edward "Brill" Lyle—a paranoid former NSA surveillance expert operating out of a caged-off audio workshop, wearing the exact same translucent raincoat, and even sporting Harry Caul's 1974 production still as his NSA file photo.
Everyone watching knew the truth: Brill was Harry Caul. Enemy of the State was a brilliant spiritual sequel. Yet on paper, the two films could never be officially linked in canon. Because Paramount Pictures owned The Conversation and Disney’s Touchstone Pictures produced Enemy of the State, corporate copyright law forced the filmmakers to rely on visual winks and a fake name rather than giving due credit to a great idea.
This minor cinematic workaround exposes a massive flaw in how we treat culture. Under modern U.S. copyright law, corporate-owned works are locked down for 95 years—roughly five human generations.
When the Founders wrote the Copyright Clause into the U.S. Constitution, they gave Congress the power to grant exclusive rights to authors and inventors "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts." The deal was supposed to be a simple, temporary bargain: society grants creators a short monopoly (originally just 14 years, with one 14-year renewal) to incentivize new work, and in exchange, society gets permanent ownership of that work afterward so future artists can remix, adapt, and build upon it.
Somewhere along the way, that bargain was broken.
Spearheaded by the 1998 Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act—legislation pushed by lobbyists who openly wished copyright could last "forever"—copyright terms ballooned to nearly a century. As Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer noted in his dissent against the law, stretching a monopoly across five generations turns a "limited" grant into a "perpetual copyright in disguise."
A 95-year lockup doesn't incentivize new art; it creates cultural stagnation. No filmmaker writes a script or composes a score today thinking about royalties 90 years after they are dead. Worse, locking away characters and stories for nearly a century doesn't protect artists—it turns culture into corporate inventory.
Today, millions of "orphan works"—books, films, and recordings from the 20th century—sit decaying in vaults, out of print and commercially dead, yet legally untouchable by archivists or digital libraries like the Internet Archive. Even worse, modern studios routinely shelf completed movies entirely for tax write-offs, permanently banning the public from ever seeing them while retaining the rights so no one else can touch them either.
That is not how culture works. Human creativity has always thrived on iteration, continuation, and shared mythology. Shakespeare borrowed plots; fairy tales evolved through retelling; jazz musicians built standards by riffing on existing melodies.
If we want to honor the actual spirit of the Constitution, we need a "use it or lose it" clause for copyright.
Under trademark law, if a company stops actively using a brand name or logo in commerce, it eventually loses its exclusive claim to it. Copyright should operate on a similar principle. After an initial 20-year window of exclusivity—more than enough time for a studio or publisher to recoup its investment and profit—rights holders should have to prove they are actively keeping the work alive. If they aren't making the book, film, or character commercially available, or if they haven't meaningfully extended the story, those rights should expire and flow back into the public domain.
At the very least, dormant characters should enter a compulsory licensing phase after two decades, allowing any creator to build a legitimate sequel or adaptation in exchange for a small, standardized royalty to the original rights holder.
Culture is meant to be a living conversation, not a museum exhibit locked behind velvet ropes for five generations. If corporations aren't going to use the stories they own, they shouldn't be allowed to stop the rest of us from telling the next chapter.
No comments:
Post a Comment