J. Rogers, SE Ohio
Abstract
Classical mechanics is conventionally described as the low-speed limit of special relativity. We construct the mapping explicitly as a functor from a relativistic kinematic grammar 𝓡 to a classical one 𝓒, and show that its failure to be an exact functor is first-order in a single dimensionless number, γ − 1. Composition of boosts is preserved up to a relative defect of at most 2σ, and every sentence the classical grammar returns differs from its relativistic counterpart by an order-one multiple of γ − 1. The scope of the classical grammar is therefore the condition γ − 1 < σ, where σ is the resolution of the instrument taking the reading. Speed does not appear in the boundary; it appears only when the boundary is restated in a chosen unit chart, where it reads v = c√(2σ). We also list the relativistic sentences that have no classical image, and give the resulting scope entry for the contract schema proposed in Self-Explaining Meta-Grammars.
This paper describes the form of the mapping between two descriptions. It makes no claim about what stands behind either.
1. Setting
In this paper a grammar is a set of primitives, production rules, and the sentences they generate, as in Frameworks as Grammars. A functor between grammars sends primitives to primitives and derivations to derivations while preserving composition. We build one such functor, for one pair of grammars, in full.
Chart. We work in the rational chart with c = 1, so that velocity is the dimensionless β = v/c. In SI, c is the exchange rate between the length and time channels, and β is the same dimensionless reading with that rate divided out. Nothing below depends on the chart; γ − 1 is a ratio of two readings of one cut and is unchanged under any rescaling of units.
The relativistic grammar 𝓡.
- Primitives: invariant mass m, and rapidity φ of a body in the chosen frame.
- Derived readings: β = tanh φ, γ = cosh φ, energy E = γm, momentum p = γmβ, with the production rule E² = p² + m².
- Morphisms: boosts. Boosts compose by adding rapidity: φ₁ then φ₂ is φ₁ + φ₂.
The classical grammar 𝓒.
- Primitives: mass m and velocity v of a body in the chosen frame.
- Derived readings: momentum p = mv, kinetic energy T = ½mv².
- Morphisms: Galilean boosts. Boosts compose by adding velocity: v₁ then v₂ is v₁ + v₂.
2. The Functor F_σ
The domain. Fix σ > 0. Let 𝓡_σ be the partial category whose objects are the states of 𝓡 with γ − 1 < σ, and whose morphisms are the boosts with γ − 1 < σ whose composite, when composed, also satisfies the bound. Composites that leave the region are not morphisms of 𝓡_σ. This is the content of the word scope: the functor is defined only where the grammar is used.
On objects. F_σ(m, φ) = (m, v = tanh φ). The invariant mass becomes the classical mass, and the velocity is read off as β.
On morphisms. F_σ(boost by φ) = Galilean boost by tanh φ.
On identities. F_σ(0) = 0 exactly.
On composition. This is the step that fails to be exact. For boosts φ₁ and φ₂ with t_i = tanh φ_i:
- F_σ(φ₁ + φ₂) = tanh(φ₁ + φ₂) = (t₁ + t₂) / (1 + t₁t₂)
- F_σ(φ₂) ∘ F_σ(φ₁) = t₁ + t₂
The two differ, and F_σ is therefore a functor only up to a defect, which we bound next.
3. The Composition Defect
Proposition 1. For collinear boosts in 𝓡_σ, the relative defect in composition is
δ = [ (t₁ + t₂) − (t₁ + t₂)/(1 + t₁t₂) ] / (t₁ + t₂) = t₁t₂ / (1 + t₁t₂) ≤ t₁t₂ ≤ 2σ.
Proof. The first equality is algebra: the numerator is (t₁ + t₂)·t₁t₂/(1 + t₁t₂), and dividing by t₁ + t₂ leaves t₁t₂/(1 + t₁t₂). The bound t₁t₂ ≤ 2σ follows from the region. A boost in 𝓡_σ has γ − 1 < σ, so with γ = 1 + σ at the edge, β² = 1 − 1/γ² = σ(2 + σ)/(1 + σ)². The inequality (2 + σ)/(1 + σ)² ≤ 2 holds for all σ ≥ 0, since it reduces to 2 + σ ≤ 2 + 4σ + 2σ². So β² ≤ 2σ for each boost, and t₁t₂ ≤ max(t₁², t₂²) ≤ 2σ. ∎
For boosts in opposite directions the relative defect is not the natural measure, since the composite can be near zero. The absolute defect, as a fraction of c, is |t₁ + t₂|·t₁t₂/(1 + t₁t₂), which is at most about 2β_max³ and is third order in β.
Corollary. F_σ is an ε-functor with ε = 2σ: identities are preserved exactly, and composition is preserved to relative error at most 2σ. Within an instrument whose resolution is σ or coarser, the failure of exact functoriality cannot be read off, and F_σ behaves as a functor for every purpose the instrument supports.
The choice of the word approximate is deliberate. We do not claim equality where we have shown a bounded difference, and we do not claim a difference where the instrument cannot resolve one. These are different statements, and the contract keeps them apart.
4. The Sentences
A functor between grammars also carries sentences. For each reading the two grammars both produce, the deviation is a function of γ alone.
Reading | Relativistic (𝓡) | Classical (𝓒) | Relative deviation |
|---|---|---|---|
Momentum | γmβ | mβ | exactly γ − 1 |
Kinetic energy | (γ − 1)m | ½mβ² | (2γ + 1)(γ − 1)/(γ + 1) ≈ 1.5(γ − 1) |
Velocity composition | (t₁ + t₂)/(1 + t₁t₂) | t₁ + t₂ | t₁t₂/(1 + t₁t₂) ≲ 2(γ − 1) |
Clock rate of the moving body | 1/γ | 1 | ≈ γ − 1 |
Length of the moving body along the motion | 1/γ | 1 | ≈ γ − 1 |
The momentum row follows because p_rel/p_cl = γ. The kinetic-energy row follows from T_rel/T_cl = 2(γ − 1)/β² = 2γ²/(γ + 1), whose deviation from 1 is (2γ² − γ − 1)/(γ + 1) = (2γ + 1)(γ − 1)/(γ + 1). The last two rows are the factors the classical grammar has no sentence for, so its implicit value is 1.
Every row has the form k·(γ − 1) with k of order one (k = 1, 1.5, 2, 1, 1). The deviation function is thus one dimensionless number times a bounded coefficient, and the coefficient depends on which sentence is being used.
5. Scope Is Precision, Not Speed
Scope condition. Let σ_c be the resolution of the instrument in the channel c being read. The classical sentence for that channel is indistinguishable from the relativistic one when
k_c·(γ − 1) < σ_c.
The coefficients k_c differ by channel and are all of order one. The scope is therefore set by σ, and the body's state enters only through γ − 1.
The velocity is a derived label for the boundary. Inverting γ − 1 = σ gives
v/c = √(2σ + σ²)/(1 + σ), which is v/c ≈ √(2σ) to first order,
with the neglected terms of relative size σ, far below what σ can resolve. In the c = 1 chart this is v = √(2σ). Precision goes in and a speed comes out as a restatement in the reader's chart.
Instrument resolution σ | Boundary v = c√(2σ) |
|---|---|
10⁻⁶ (a good bench instrument) | about 424 km/s |
10⁻¹⁰ (an atomic-clock channel) | about 4.24 km/s |
Body | γ − 1 |
|---|---|
A truck at 30 m/s | about 5 × 10⁻¹⁵ |
Earth in its orbit, 29.8 km/s | about 5 × 10⁻⁹ |
A GPS satellite, 3.87 km/s | about 8 × 10⁻¹¹ |
The same body falls on either side of the boundary depending on the reading. The GPS satellite is classical for navigation, where positions are resolved to much worse than 10⁻¹⁰, and not classical for its onboard clock, which resolves the rate offset directly. Nothing about the satellite differs between the two cases. Only σ does.
This keeps a distinction the standard phrase "classical mechanics is valid at low speed" erases: a deviation below σ cannot be read, which says nothing about whether the deviation is zero. Improve the instrument and the same system leaves the contract.
6. What F_σ Does Not Map
The functor is not full, and the relativistic sentences that have no classical image are the ones the classical grammar has no primitive for.
- Rest energy. E = γm has the term m (that is, mc²) as its value at γ = 1. The classical energy ½mv² is defined up to an additive constant, and F_σ sends the relativistic energy to E − m. The rest energy is not discarded. It is the zero of the classical energy chart, an offset that drops out of every energy difference the classical grammar takes.
- Mass conservation. The classical grammar conserves m separately from energy. In 𝓡 only the sum is conserved, and invariant mass changes by ΔE/c² when energy ΔE leaves a system. The classical statement holds where ΔE/(mc²) < σ. For combustion that ratio is about 10⁻¹⁰, and for fission and fusion it is 10⁻³ to 10⁻², so chemical bookkeeping is classical at most resolutions and nuclear bookkeeping is not.
- Massless states. A photon has m = 0, so F_σ has no object to send it to. The classical grammar has no sentence for it.
- Speeds at and beyond c. The classical grammar has Galilean boosts with v ≥ c, and 𝓡 has no preimage for them. The domain 𝓡_σ already excludes them.
- Time and length factors. 1/γ is a factor in 𝓡 with no classical symbol, which is why the last two rows of the table in section 4 carry an implicit classical value of 1.
In the vocabulary of the contract schema, this list is the "stops parsing" field of the classical grammar.
7. Relation to Prior Work
The mapping above is a concrete case of group contraction, introduced by Inönü and Wigner, in which the Poincaré group contracts to the Galilei group as the parameter 1/c² goes to zero. Lévy-Leblond developed the non-relativistic limit of the Poincaré group in the same spirit. The standard treatment takes the contraction parameter to be a physical limit, c → ∞. We take it to be the instrument's resolution: the contraction parameter at which two sentences become indistinguishable is a property of the cut, set by σ, and c itself is the exchange rate between two of our channels, not a quantity that can be taken to a limit.
The construction is also an instance of the matching practice in effective field theory, in which each description is used within a domain and results are matched across the boundary. The contract below makes that practice explicit for a single pair.
8. The Contract Entry
The schema proposed in Self-Explaining Meta-Grammars has one entry per grammar. For classical kinematics:
- Takes in: a body's mass and velocity in a chosen frame.
- Returns: momentum mv, kinetic energy ½mv², and Galilean composition of boosts.
- Scope: k_c·(γ − 1) < σ_c, with k_c of order one for the channel c and σ_c the resolution of the reading.
- Exchange rate at the boundary: c, the length-to-time conversion; in the rational chart c = 1 and the boundary is stated directly in γ − 1.
- Stops parsing: rest energy as anything other than a zero offset, separate mass conservation under energy exchange, massless states, speeds at or beyond c, and the clock-rate and length factors.
- Return mapping: results leave in the classical chart and enter the caller in whatever chart the caller uses, by the unit-chart tool's exchange rates.
Every other grammar's scope line can take the same form: a deviation function between its sentence and the incumbent's, and the resolution of the reading it is compared with.
9. What Is and Is Not Claimed
This paper constructs one functor, for one pair of grammars, with the defect bounded and the sentences tabulated. It does not claim that every pair of grammars admits such a map, that the coefficients k_c are the same for other sentences than the five listed, or anything about general relativity, where the two grammars share no common chart and the same method does not directly apply. The coefficients for sentences beyond kinematics are open, and each requires its own derivation.
The result is narrower than "classical is the low-speed limit," and sharper: the boundary is a number that belongs to the reading, and the functor says how far the classical sentence can be trusted for any reading whose resolution is known.
References
- Rogers, J. Self-Explaining Meta-Grammars.
- Rogers, J. Frameworks as Grammars: Normal Science, Reification, and the Gödelian Boundary of Description.
- Inönü, E., and Wigner, E. P. (1953). On the contraction of groups and their representations. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 39, 510–524.
- Lévy-Leblond, J.-M. (1965). Une nouvelle limite non-relativiste du groupe de Poincaré. Annales de l'Institut Henri Poincaré A, 3, 1–12.
- Newton, I. (1687). Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica, Scholium to the Definitions.
No comments:
Post a Comment