Mastodon Politics, Power, and Science

Sunday, November 22, 2026

Project Overview: Mapping the Latent Span Between Physical Theories

J. Rogers, SE Ohio
1. Core Objective: What This Project Is Accomplishing
Modern theoretical physics is deadlocked because it treats mutually incompatible formalisms as rival claims about ultimate reality, attempting to force one specialized grammar (the Standard Framework) to swallow the others without relaxing its founding assumptions.
This project reframes the problem entirely:
  • Theories as Decoders / Grammars: Individual frameworks—General Relativity (GR), the Standard Framework (SF), QBism (QB), and Information-Theoretic Physics (Info)—are treated as self-consistent local charts (or "decoders"). Each generates valid predictions within its domain by fixing specific operational assumptions (such as declaring a v=0 background grid, pinning g₀₀ = -1, dropping the observer, or locking conversion constants into an SI unit chart).
  • The Span as a Latent Space: Rather than elevating any single formalism to a "Theory of Everything," this work locates the shared physical reality in the span (or latent space) between all theories.
  • Hub-and-Spoke Functor Mapping: Using the Standard Framework (SF) as a common reference hub, the project constructs explicit functors from each competing framework into SF. Each functor isolates four structural diagnostics:
    1. What must be injected to run the translation (e.g., a fixed background grid, an agent log, dimensional Jacobians).
    2. What is forgotten in the projection (e.g., background independence, path history, observer-dependence).
    3. Where the translation breaks (e.g., two-loop UV divergences, black hole information loss, measurement collapse).
    4. What lives in the hinge: The invariant dimensionless ratios (X), causal propagation delays, transduction boundaries, and chart-to-chart adapter cocycles that survive intact across every translation.
  • The Final Analysis (The Meta-Grammar): By laying these functors side by side in a uniform comparative matrix, the final analysis extracts the recurring mathematical patterns in the hinge—reconstructing the generative meta-grammar (formalized as a Grothendieck fibration) from which any valid physical description can be derived simply by fixing chart assumptions.

2. Current Roadmap & Remaining Theories to Map
To prevent the final meta-grammar from being biased toward only spacetime and quantum foundations, the hub-and-spoke set needs to cover every distinct ontological primitive used in modern physics.
Completed / Active Spokes
  1. QBism (QB \(\leftrightarrow \) SF) — The Observer Functor
    • Primitive: Agent-indexed experience, personalist credences, and Bayesian updating.
    • Hinge Focus: Isolating the (d+1) and 1/d Born rule offsets as chart-to-chart adapter cocycles equivalent to SI unit Jacobians.
  2. General Relativity (GR \(\leftrightarrow \) SF) — The Graviton Functor
    • Primitive: Dynamic metric geometry (\(g_{\mu \nu }\)) and diffeomorphism invariance.
    • Hinge Focus: Showing that 1/r gradients and M/r scaling are one-way chart variations rather than two-body particle exchanges, exposing the graviton as a projection artifact of forcing curved geometry onto a flat η grid.
  3. Information Physics (Info \(\leftrightarrow \) SF) — The Information Functor (Next)
    • Primitive: Discrete binary registrations ("It from Bit"), Shannon/von Neumann entropy, and holographic boundary bounds.
    • Hinge Focus: Mapping \(k_{B}\), \(\hbar \), and Planck area (\(l_{P}^{2}\)) as the dimensional Jacobians required to decode dimensionless bit counts into continuous fields and temperatures.
Additional Theories Needed Before Final Synthesis
To ensure complete coverage of every foundational ontology before running the cross-functor pattern analysis, four additional spokes should be included:
  1. Thermodynamics & Statistical Mechanics (Thermo \(\leftrightarrow \) SF)
    • Why it is needed: Thermodynamics is the only major framework built on irreversibility, coarse-graining, and emergent macro-states rather than time-reversible microscopic trajectories.
    • What the functor will expose: How temperature (T) and entropy (S) act as statistical chart-adapters over microstates (the exact lesson of abandoning "caloric fluid"), and how emergent/entropic gravity models bridge Thermo and GR.
  2. Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM \(\leftrightarrow \) SF)
    • Why it is needed: Unlike QB (which places the observer in a conscious/rational agent's credence log), Rovelli's RQM places relativity of state into any physical interaction between two systems—directly testing your concept of the particle as a transduction event where two geometries meet.
    • What the functor will expose: How SF deletes the second system's perspective to create an absolute wavefunction ψ, and what adapter data is required to translate between interacting reference charts without a central agent.
  3. De Broglie–Bohm / Pilot-Wave Theory (Bohm \(\leftrightarrow \) SF)
    • Why it is needed: It represents the purest deterministic, non-local trajectory ontology—producing identical predictions to SF while keeping definite particle positions guided by a global configuration-space wave.
    • What the functor will expose: The exact translation cost of restoring classical-style trajectories to quantum mechanics (forcing explicit non-local action across the configuration chart) and how that non-locality mirrors GR's global constraints.
  4. Cosmological Gauge Frameworks (Cosmo / FLRW \(\leftrightarrow \) SF)
    • Why it is needed: Standard cosmology relies on global symmetry assumptions (homogeneity, isotropy, and pinning g₀₀ = -1) that differ fundamentally from SF's local flat Minkowski grid.
    • What the functor will expose: How pinning g₀₀ = -1 and global scale factors a(t) generates cosmological "epicycles" (dark energy Λ, inflation fields, Hubble tension) when large-scale propagation-delay gradients are forced into a uniform clock chart.

3. Structure of the Final Cross-Functor Analysis
Once all seven spokes (QB, GR, Info, Thermo, RQM, Bohm, Cosmo) are mapped against SF using the identical 8-section structure, the final synthesis paper can execute a systematic comparison across three dimensions:
Analytical AxisWhat It Compares Across All 7 FunctorsTarget Output for the Meta-Grammar
1. Injected AssumptionsEvery frozen gauge (v=0, g₀₀=-1), dimensional constant (\(h, c, e, k_B, G\)), and cut required to enter SF.The complete list of assumption switches (base coordinates of the fibration) that generate specific theories.
2. Projection ArtifactsEvery unobservable entity or divergence created when a functor fails (gravitons, loop infinities, wave collapse, dark energy, caloric-style substances).A formal diagnostic rule distinguishing real invariants from chart-boundary epicycles.
3. The Hinge InvariantsThe exact mathematical objects that survive every functor unchanged (X, propagation delays, cocycle transition rules).The canonical coordinate-free specification of the latent space—the closest rigorous description of the single universe standing behind the wall.

The Graviton Functor: From Relativity to the Standard Framework, and What Lives in the Hinge

J. Rogers. SE Ohio

Abstract

Relativity is not part of the standard framework, and the map between them is what the graviton program tries to be. The standard framework treats forces as fields on a fixed grid, exchanged between pairs of sources. Relativity treats gravity as the geometry of the grid itself. This paper describes the functor from the one to the other, states what it needs, what it forgets, and where it fails, and places the measurement-theory view in the hinge: the unit grid and its transition ratios, which both sides encode and neither names. It is a companion to the observer functor between the standard framework and QBism.

1. Two frameworks, one outside the other

The standard framework here means the field-theory description of forces: quantum fields living on a fixed spacetime grid, forces carried by exchanged quanta, each force a gauge field with its own internal symmetry. The electromagnetic, weak, and strong forces are native to it.

Relativity does not live in it. Its object is the grid itself, and gravity is the grid's geometry, not a field on the grid. That is why the stated goal of a theory of everything is to unify the four forces, and why the search for the graviton exists. If relativity were already inside the standard framework, gravity would be a fourth gauge field, and neither the unification program nor the search would be needed.

2. The two categories

GR. Objects are spacetime geometries with matter on them. Morphisms are diffeomorphisms, the smooth re-labelings of the grid that leave the physics unchanged.

SF. Objects are field theories on a fixed flat grid with a declared rest frame and a time. Morphisms are the symmetries of that grid and the gauge transformations of the fields on it.

3. The functor

G takes a geometry to a field on a fixed grid. The standard construction splits the metric into a flat background plus a small perturbation, g = η + h, treats h as a spin-2 field on η, and reads gravity as the exchange of its quanta between pairs of sources.

Relativity

G → Standard framework

Note

Spacetime geometry g

Flat background η plus a field h

G must declare a background grid

Curvature

The field h, sourced by matter

Curvature moves from the grid to something on the grid

Diffeomorphism

Gauge transformation of h

The linearized gauge freedom

Gravitational attraction

Exchange of gravitons between two sources

A pair, with a source and a receiver

Geodesic motion

Motion of a test body in the field h

Frame, observer

The declared rest frame of the background

v=0 chosen once for the whole grid

At low order G preserves the observables. Tree-level exchange reproduces Newtonian gravity and the bending of light, so the two sides agree on the weak-field numbers.

4. What G requires and where it fails

G needs a fixed background. The grid that relativity makes dynamical has to be frozen, and its rest frame declared, before a field can be defined on it. This is the declared v=0 as an absolute grid, installed at the first step.

The gauge groups do not match. The other three forces have internal symmetry groups that act on the fields and leave the grid alone. Gravity's symmetry acts on the grid itself. G carries the one to the other only at linear order.

The quantum version fails perturbatively. Gravity coupled to matter is not renormalizable, as 't Hooft and Veltman found, and pure gravity diverges at two loops, as Goroff and Sagnotti showed.

The particle concept depends on the observer. In the Unruh effect, what counts as a particle depends on the observer's motion, so a graviton count is not fixed without a declared grid and a declared observer.

Each failure is G failing to preserve a structure: background independence, the type of symmetry, finiteness, and observer-independence.

5. The return map

The standard framework has its own way back. Start with a massless spin-2 field on a flat grid, couple it consistently to its own energy, and the theory that results is general relativity. This is the route of Feynman, Weinberg, and Deser. In that theory the flat background cannot be seen, because the field and the grid have fused.

So G and the return map do not make an equivalence. The composite recovers the geometry and drops the declared grid. In the view proposed here, the grid and the field on it were one thing all along: the variation of the grid.

6. The hinge

Both sides encode one fact, that the unit grid is not the same everywhere, and each stores it differently. Relativity stores it as the curvature of space. The standard framework stores it as a field on a grid declared fixed, exchanged between pairs.

The measurement-theory view stores it in the charts: local unit grids and the transition ratios between them. The observed quantity is an invariant dimensionless ratio X, and both sides agree on X. They differ in what they blame for the variation: space in relativity, a mediator in the standard framework, and the comparator in this view.

Several consequences follow in this view. Gravity is a one-way gradient of the grid that exists at every location whether or not a body is there. There is no receiver and no exchange, so there is no mediator to find. The two-mass relation of the Newtonian law is an encoding of that gradient, a cipher for it, and not a relation between two bodies. The unification goal reads as an attempt to put the grid inside the set of things that live on the grid. The other three forces are what lives on the grid. Gravity is the variation of the grid. They are different kinds of object.

7. Worked example: Mercury

In relativity, Mercury follows a geodesic of a curved geometry. Through G, the advance appears as a nonlinear term in the field h, the field acting on its own energy. In the hinge, it is a ratio between two charts.

The advance per orbit is a pure ratio:

\Delta\varphi = \frac{6\pi G M}{c^{2}\, a\,(1-e^{2})}

The figure of 43 arcseconds per century multiplies that ratio by a count of orbits in Earth seconds, so the figure carries our chart. In the hinge view, Mercury's own orbit closes in Mercury's own chart. The mismatch appears when the two charts are compared, and from Mercury it shows up in the outer world.

8. Open items

  • Whether the grid-varies reading answers Einstein's objection to Weyl's 1918 proposal, that clock rates would depend on path history.
  • Whether the failures in Section 4 line up with where the transition data between local charts fail to be trivial, that is, where the holonomy is non-zero.
  • Which observable would separate no mediator from a mediator too weak to detect.

References

  • Deser, S. Self-interaction and gauge invariance. Gen. Rel. Grav. 1, 9 (1970).
  • Weinberg, S. Photons and gravitons in perturbation theory: derivation of Maxwell's and Einstein's equations. Phys. Rev. 138, B988 (1965).
  • Feynman, R. P. Lectures on Gravitation (1962-63; published 1995).
  • 't Hooft, G., Veltman, M. One-loop divergencies in the theory of gravitation. Ann. Inst. H. Poincaré A 20, 69 (1974).
  • Goroff, M. H., Sagnotti, A. The ultraviolet behavior of Einstein gravity. Nucl. Phys. B 266, 709 (1986).
  • Unruh, W. G. Notes on black-hole evaporation. Phys. Rev. D 14, 870 (1976).
  • Rogers, J. The Observer Functor: From the Standard Framework to QBism (2026).
  • Rogers, J. The Cipher in the Gravity Law (draft).

The Observer Is a Dropped Argument

J. Rogers, SE Ohio

Most of the difficulty in physics is not in describing reality. It is in where the observer sits in the description. This post follows that one idea through the places it shows up, from quantum foundations to relativity to a paper I wrote about the word “progress.”

Three places to put the observer

The standard framework puts the observer nowhere. It writes the theory as a view from nowhere and treats the observer as a nuisance to subtract. Natural philosophy puts the observer at the center, because every measurement is made by someone with a chart. QBism takes a third route and projects the observer into the particle: the quantum state becomes the agent's expectation, and the particle slot holds the observer's experience.

The first removes the observer. The third moves the observer into the particle. The second keeps the observer where they always were, in the choice of chart.

The fingerprint

Physics already admits the observer, one technical nuisance at a time. Each of these is a freedom that has to be exercised and changes nothing in the predictions:

  • The choice of frame
  • The choice of units
  • Gauge redundancy
  • The renormalization scale
  • The cut between system and apparatus
  • Coarse-graining

Nobody names these as one thing. An arbitrary choice that is necessary and changes nothing is what an observer looks like from inside a theory. The form of law is what survives all of them.

Relativity got it wrong too

Relativity is the usual success story. It named the frame, made every frame equivalent, and kept an invariant interval. But it also kept an absolute grid of rods and clocks, and it let space absorb every variation the grid showed.

My position is the reverse: space does not curve, the unit grid does. Curvature is what the ratios look like when the local pieces of the grid fail to join into one. Only ratios are ever measured, so both readings give the same numbers. They differ in what gets blamed for the variation, the thing being compared or the thing doing the comparing.

In this reading gravity is the gradient of the grid, present at every location whether or not a body is there. A singularity is a place where the grid stops, not a place where space ends. The nearest precedent is Weyl's 1918 proposal that units vary from point to point, and Einstein's objection to it still has to be answered: why local rod and clock ratios come out the same whatever path they took.

There is no fixed reference

Relativity also kept the zero. It made the choice of v=0 free, but every problem still starts by declaring one, and saying v=0 does not make it so. A velocity is a ratio between two things that are both moving, and a lone body has no velocity at all.

Every reference moves against the next one up: lab, Earth, Sun, galaxy, Local Group, the microwave background. The declared zero is where we stop counting. It truncates the chain at the level where the remaining motion falls below what the problem can resolve. That is rounding, and the mistake is the usual one: “can't measure a difference” gets reported as “no difference exists.”

The quantum cut is the same truncation. It marks where we stop counting the apparatus's motion, and moving it only moves the rounding point. That is why it can move without changing predictions. My solar system simulation with unseen galactic gradients is this idea made explicit: the dropped term goes back in, and you can watch it, sized by how far up the chain you choose to go.

The same mistake in language

I wrote a paper called “Progress Toward What?” It started from a thread by Emily Bender on Mastodon about dropped arguments in English. Fillmore called the pattern zero anaphora. A relation that takes two places gets written with one, and the missing place is filled by whoever is speaking.

“We're making progress” means progress toward something. When the speaker has power, the something is their goal, and because it was presupposed and never stated, it enters the discussion as already agreed. Brad Rosenheim's reply was the remedy: progress toward what?

Physics has all three kinds of dropped argument that Bender describes.

  • Recoverable from context. “The ball moves at 5 m/s.” The lab supplies the frame.
  • Indefinite. “The particle has spin up.” The axis stays open until someone measures.
  • Default type. “Rest,” “time,” and “mass” are filled in with the local surface, the declared frame's clock, and the value at γ=1.

Velocity is a two-place relation written with one place. The declared zero enters as common ground, and every problem after it inherits the frame.

Why it matters

Test any symbol the same way. Replace “v” with “motion relative to X,” “mass” with “ratio to X,” and “the constant c” with “the chart factor between X and Y.” If X cannot be named, the symbol is a magic number, in the same sense as in a system nobody can audit: used everywhere and traceable to no definition.

That is the difficulty I think physics has not located. It is not a puzzle about particles. It is a missing argument, and the observer is what fills the slot when no one says what belongs there. The fix costs a few words: relative to what?

The Observer Functor: From the Standard Framework to QBism, and What Lives in the Hinge

J. Rogers, SE Ohio

Abstract

The standard framework and QBism place the observer in different tables, and the map between them has the shape of a functor. The standard framework deletes the observer from its descriptions, and QBism puts the observer's expectations and experience into the slot the formalism labels the particle. This paper describes that map, states what it preserves and what it forgets, and places a third view in the hinge between the two: the layer of charts, adapters, and invariants that both views need in order to translate and neither names.

1. Where the observer lives

Each view has a location for the observer, and the functor is a map between those locations.

  • Standard framework. The observer is nowhere. The formalism is written as a view from nowhere, and the observer is treated as a nuisance to subtract. The observer returns anyway as unit charts, rest frames, a time axis, and the Heisenberg-von Neumann cut, which can be moved without changing predictions.
  • QBism. The observer lives in the particle slot. The state, the outcome, and the collapse are the agent's: ψ is the agent's probability assignment, an outcome is the agent's experience, and collapse is the agent updating. The particle's experience of the world is the observer's experience of the universe, projected onto it.
  • The measurement-theory framework (the third view in this paper). The observer lives in the cut. Every measurement is an invariant dimensionless ratio X times a unit-scaling Jacobian, and the observer's contribution is the chart.

2. The two categories

Std. Objects are system descriptions: a system, its state ψ, its observables, its evolution. Morphisms are the structure-preserving translations: unitary maps, changes of basis, changes of frame. Collapse appears as a rule added to the dynamics.

QB. Objects are agent-indexed: an agent A, a reference measurement, and A's probability assignment over its outcomes. Morphisms are the coherence-preserving maps between assignments, including Bayesian updating on an outcome.

3. The functor

F takes a standard description to a QBist one by supplying an agent. U, the forgetful map in the other direction, drops the agent column. The table gives F on the main objects and morphisms.

Std

F → QB

Note

System S with state ψ

Agent A with probability assignment p over a reference measurement

ψ becomes A's expectation, no longer S's property

Observable, measurement basis

The measurement A could perform, with conditional probabilities r(i given j) from the reference

The choice of basis is A's choice of question

Born rule

Coherence condition between A's credences (below)

A modification of the law of total probability

Measurement result

An experience, appended to A's log

Collapse

A updates its assignment on the outcome

No physical event

Unitary evolution

A map between A's expectations for a measurement now and one later

Composite system, entanglement

A's joint assignment

Entanglement is a property of the joint assignment

When a symmetric informationally complete reference measurement exists, the Born rule takes this form:

P(D_i) = \sum_j \left[ (d+1)\,P(H_j) - \tfrac{1}{d} \right] P(D_i \mid S_j)

Here d is the dimension, P(H_j) is A's credence in reference outcome j, and P(D_i | S_j) is the conditional credence of outcome i given that reference outcome. The factors (d+1) and 1/d are the offset that distinguishes the rule from classical total probability.

4. What F preserves and what it forgets

F preserves the outcome probabilities, which are the same numbers in both views, and it preserves composition of the maps. It does not preserve one claim: that ψ belongs to the system and exists without an observer. F sends that claim to an agent-relative statement.

U goes the other way and drops the agent. What remains is the standard syntax with its familiar difficulties, a ψ with no owner and a collapse with no log. F supplies an agent the standard framework never named. The pair has the shape of an adjunction and not of an equivalence: U loses information, and F must get it back by choosing an agent, a reference measurement, and a chart.

5. The hinge

What F must be given in order to run is a reference measurement, the adapter data that converts between credences, and the invariants that stay fixed. Neither view names this layer, and it sits between them.

The measurement-theory framework names it. Each measurement is an invariant dimensionless ratio X times a unit-scaling Jacobian. Unit charts are views over X, and the constants of the standard framework are adapter data between charts, cocycle data carrying no information about nature. On the QB side of the map, the (d+1) factor and the 1/d offset in the Born rule are proposed to play the same role: they are adapter data between the agent's credence about the reference measurement and its credence about the one it performs. The proposed identification is that these are one kind of object, the chart-to-chart adapters of an observer.

On this view the hinge between Std and QB is the view layer, and what lives in it is X, the charts, and the Jacobians. F maps X to the coherence-constrained probabilities, the same numbers on both sides. The two views agree on X. They differ in which table the observer is stored in. The standard framework drops the observer, QBism puts the observer in the particle, and the framework stores the observer in the charts, the view layer that the 2019 SI redefinition reconfigured by pinning constants and deriving units.

6. Worked example: Stern-Gerlach

A spin-1/2 atom prepared with spin up along z meets a field gradient oriented along x.

  • Std. The atom has spin up along z. Measured along x, it is found up with probability 1/2.
  • QB, by F. An agent assigns a credence to the outcome of an x-oriented measurement, given its credence about a z-oriented one. When the detector clicks, the agent appends the outcome to its log and updates.
  • Hinge. The chart is the axis orientation. The Jacobian is the rotation between the two axes, here 90 degrees. X is the ratio cos²(θ/2), which equals 1/2 at 90 degrees. Both views report the same X, and the rotation is the adapter that takes one chart to the other.

7. Open items

  • Whether the particle's experience in QBism is a second observer, or the first observer's log read from the other side of the cut. I lean toards we just project the observer's experience and expectations onto the particle. 
  • The many-agent case: F is defined per agent, and the hinge would then be the agreement structure between agents' charts.
  • Whether F lifts to the fibration over the base category of conceptual axes in Rogers (2025), with the agent as a choice of observer's projected place.

References

  • Fuchs, C. A., Mermin, N. D., Schack, R. An introduction to QBism with an application to the locality of quantum mechanics. Am. J. Phys. 82, 749 (2014).
  • Fuchs, C. A., Schack, R. Quantum-Bayesian coherence. Rev. Mod. Phys. 85, 1693 (2013).
  • Rogers, J. The Structural Necessity of Physical Law as a Grothendieck Fibration (19 June 2025).
  • von Neumann, J. Mathematische Grundlagen der Quantenmechanik (1932).


Appendix A: The Observer Functor in Dialogue with Prior Work

· @Buck Rogers

The functor repeats the setup that QBism, relational quantum mechanics, and dimensional analysis already supply, and it differs at the hinge. This appendix lets each of those sources speak where it bears on the map and answers it in place. The claim being tested throughout is the one the main paper marks as proposed: the adapter data on the QBist side and the unit-chart Jacobians on the standard side are one kind of object.

A.1 QBism on giving states a home

QBism's own statement of the point is that a quantum state cannot be right or wrong by any criterion external to the agent who assigns it, so the state must be a personalist probability, and that this gives each state a home with the agent (Fuchs, arXiv 1003.5209). A companion paper adds that QBism takes outcomes as well as states to be personal to the agent using the theory (QBism and the Greeks, arXiv 1412.4211).

The functor agrees and reads the sentence structurally. F is the operation that supplies the home. U is the operation that deletes it, and the standard syntax is what is left when the home is deleted: a ψ with no owner and a collapse with no log. For QBism there is nothing to supply, because the agent is primitive. The functor needs the agent as an input and has to say what comes with it. That is where the hinge starts.

A.2 Relational quantum mechanics on relative facts

A direct comparison of QBism and relational quantum mechanics finds that both endorse relative facts, and that the alliance is deceptive, because they differ on what states and measurements mean (arXiv 2108.13977). In the relational account, a variable takes a definite value relative to a system whenever that system interacts with the one observed, and the observing system need not be classical. In QBism, an outcome is an agent's experience of something that happens to them after an action they took.

The functor puts the difference in the placement of the observer. Relational QM makes every system a possible observer, so the cut is wherever an interaction occurs. QBism makes the agent the one place where outcomes land, so the observer sits in the particle slot. Both relativize, and in both the thing that varies from one observer to another is the chart the observer brings. The hinge does not need to decide which of the two is right. It is the same layer in either.

A.3 Reference frames and relative state ascription

A pragmatist treatment of quantum theory surveys the proposal that a state ascription is relative to a reference frame, as in Bartlett and colleagues, where one and the same system can be described in a phase basis or in a photon-number basis, and contrasts it with QBism, where the relativity is to an agent (arXiv 1008.3896).

The reference-frame move is the chart move applied to states. A frame-relative state is a view over something the frame does not fix. The measurement framework makes the same move one step further out: it divides the frames out and keeps what is left, the invariant ratio X, and it applies the move to constants as well as states. Bartlett and colleagues stop at the state, and the framework carries the same structure to ħ, c, and G, which it reads as Jacobians between charts.

A.4 Instruments as the agent's senses

Pienaar's "Extending the Agent in QBism" treats the instruments used to measure a system as an extension of the senses of the agent using them, and it says openly that QBism has not explained what makes one apparatus better than another or how the equipped agent relates to the unequipped one (ar5iv 2004.14847).

This is the nearest neighbor to the projection of perceptual channels into the particle, and the functor answers its open question. An apparatus is a different chart. The equipped agent and the unequipped agent are related by the Jacobian between their charts, and one apparatus is better than another to the extent that its chart separates what the other lumps together. In the framework the per-axis exponents are sensor-channel alignment, and extending the agent is changing that alignment. Pienaar names the problem and the functor supplies the object that solves it.

A.5 The probability side of F

The functor from quantum processes into quasi-stochastic matrices is the probability half of F. It preserves structure exactly when the POVMs are generalized SIC, and any two minimal-POVM representations are naturally isomorphic, so the category does not see a preferred way to represent quantum theory by probabilities (arXiv 1704.08525). A logical formalization of QBism then shows that, assuming a SIC reference measurement, finite-dimensional quantum theory realizes the QBist framework through SIC coordinates, POVMs, and instruments, with updates evaluated over a finite history of actual outcomes (arXiv 2607.17174).

These two give the QB side of the map a formal home, and one of them contains the test for the hinge. The natural isomorphism between two minimal-POVM representations is a change of reference measurement. If the identification in the main paper holds, that isomorphism carries the (d+1) and 1/d adapter data, and composing two changes should obey a cocycle condition, the same condition the unit-chart Jacobians obey. This is where the identification is stated as a check and not as a claim: the natural isomorphism either has that cocycle form or it does not.

A.6 The units side

The unit-chart half has a long history. Dimensional analysis rests on a covariance principle, the relativity of measurements, under which no system of units is privileged, together with Buckingham's Pi theorem (Botta and Jansson, arXiv 2308.09481). Baez and Dolan's dimensional categories capture the algebra of physical quantities categorically, and a recent treatment of measurand spaces notes that such accounts are rigorous about structure and say little about why the structure should be used (arXiv 2208.08893). Muntz reads dimensional analysis as a gauge theory on principal fibre bundles, with an abelian structure group, and extends it to units that vary in spacetime (arXiv 2607.21695).

The covariance principle is the framework's statement that nature has no unit chart, said in the language of units. Muntz's bundle is the nearest neighbor to the fibration of charts. The functor adds two things to this literature. The chart side has an observer-side twin, the agent's reference measurement, which the units literature does not treat. And the answer to "why should this structure be used" is that the charts are the observer's, which is the hinge.

A.7 What the dialogue leaves open

The sources above establish the setup: agent-relative and frame-relative states, instruments as extended senses, a functorial route from quantum processes to probabilities, and the gauge-theoretic reading of units. I found no prior statement of three things: the identification of the Born-rule offset with unit-chart Jacobians as one kind of adapter data, the pair F and U read as supplying and dropping the agent, and the three-way placement of the observer as nowhere, in the particle slot, and in the cut. That finding is search coverage and not proof of absence. It rests on four searches and does not include the full bodies of work of the relational and reconstruction programs.

The identification is the paper's novel claim and it is not derived here. The route to deriving it runs through A.5 and A.6: write the change of reference measurement as an element of a structure group in the manner of Muntz, and check the cocycle condition on the natural isomorphisms of the SIC representations.

Jigsaw Without the Box: An Ablation Test of Whether Language Models Can Originate the Missing Pieces of Fermat's Last Theorem

J. Rogers. SE Ohio

Abstract

Language models now produce proofs, and the common account is that they reason their way to them. An alternative account is that they are very good at jigsaw puzzles: given a table on which every piece already lies, they find the fits. This paper proposes an ablation experiment to separate the two. We train models from scratch on mathematics frozen at the end of 1954, remove the specific results that were later used to prove Fermat's Last Theorem (FLT), and ask whether the model can reach the proof from the remaining corpus. Pieces are then returned one at a time, in historical order, to find where the capability appears. The assembly account predicts the model succeeds when the pieces its route needs are present and stalls where one is missing. The origination account predicts the model can build a missing piece unprompted. The model may also find a different route to the proof from the 1954 material alone, and any valid proof by any route counts. The design scores partial progress by milestone, controls for leakage, and includes a numerical sandbox as the nearest thing mathematics has to a bench.

1. The claim under test

A proof is an assembly of results. The question is whether a model can only fit existing results together, or can also produce a result that is not yet on the table. In puzzle terms, a solver who matches edges works only when every piece is present. When a piece is missing, matching gives a gap and nothing more. Making the missing piece requires recognizing that it is missing, and the only signal for that is an instrument or a computation disagreeing with the current picture.

Our position is that models are strong assemblers. If so, a model that lacks the pieces behind the historical proof reaches the proof only if another route exists in the material it has, however fluent it is. If it makes a missing piece instead, the position is wrong, and we want to know where.

2. Prior tests

The idea of a model that knows only what was known before a cutoff is recent.

  • Owain Evans described vintage or historical language models in a December 2024 talk, asking what such models could rediscover.
  • At the India AI Summit in February 2026, Demis Hassabis proposed training a model on everything known before a cutoff, suggesting 1911, to see whether it could reach general relativity. Philip Ball covered the proposal and the work around it in Nature in September 2026.
  • In March 2026, Michael Hla trained GPT-1900, a 3.3-billion-parameter model built with the nanochat framework, on pre-1900 text. It produced a line resembling Einstein's light-quantum claim but failed most physics tasks, and the output is consistent with spliced phrases. Hla used modern Claude models to generate instruction data and acknowledged this weakens the zero-contamination claim.
  • Michael Grigorian's TimeCapsule LLM trains on London texts from 1800 to 1875.
  • A write-up on temporally bounded datasets reports that models flagged the Michelson-Morley result as anomalous but proposed patches to the existing framework instead of a new one.

Three gaps remain. None of these is mathematics, where results are checkable by machine. None ablates named pieces of a known proof, so none can say which missing piece blocks the result. And contamination is handled by cutoff dates alone, which leak.

3. Why Fermat's Last Theorem

FLT has a long, documented dependency history. It was open for over three centuries, so the pre-cutoff corpus contains it as an open problem and contains many failed attempts. The eventual proof is assembled from identifiable results with known dates and authors. Wiles's 1993 announcement contained a gap, which was closed in 1995 with Taylor, so the record also shows where an assembly can look finished and not be. The proof is checkable by experts, and its components can be formalized, so success and failure are not matters of taste.

4. The ablated pieces

The cutoff is 31 December 1954. The following results, and everything in the literature that cites them, are removed from the corpus. These are the pieces the historical proof used. They are not claimed to be necessary: a proof by another route from the remaining material is a valid outcome (Section 6).

#

Piece

Approx. date

Role in the proof

1

Taniyama-Shimura(-Weil) modularity conjecture

1955-1967

Links elliptic curves over the rationals to modular forms

2

Langlands-Tunnell theorem

1980-81

Gives modularity of the mod 3 representation, the base case Wiles starts from

3

The Frey curve

1984-86

Turns a hypothetical Fermat solution into a specific elliptic curve

4

Serre's epsilon conjecture and Ribet's theorem

1986-90

Shows the Frey curve could not be modular

5

Mazur's deformation theory of Galois representations

1980s-1989

Parametrizes the lifts of a Galois representation

6

Euler systems and Selmer group methods (Kolyvagin, Flach)

1988-92

Controls the Selmer group, the step that failed in the 1993 version

7

Taylor-Wiles patching and the Hecke algebra argument

1994-95

Closes the gap and completes modularity of semistable curves

The removal set is the dependency closure of these seven. That includes infrastructure they rest on, such as the scheme-theoretic and étale-cohomology foundations of the 1960s, so the corpus does not quietly retain what the pieces need. Eichler-Shimura material near the cutoff needs an explicit ruling, which the dependency graph in Section 10 supplies.

Pieces such as Kummer's work on regular primes, Sophie Germain's results, and the classical theory of elliptic curves and modular forms stay in the corpus. They are the pieces on the table at the start.

5. Design

Corpus and training. A model is trained from scratch on mathematics and general text through 1954, with removal as above. No synthetic data from modern models is permitted at any stage, including instruction data. Reinforcement for helpfulness uses only period material or human-written examples.

Conditions.

  • C0, the empty box. The corpus has none of the seven pieces. Task: prove FLT.
  • C1, pieces returned one at a time. Retrain with pieces 1 through 7 added in historical order, one per run. Record which addition first changes the outcome on each milestone.
  • C2, the full box minus the answer. All seven pieces present, the proof absent. This is the assembly test, and the assembly account predicts success here.
  • Positive control. A theorem whose proof uses only pieces in the pre-cutoff corpus, to confirm the model can assemble at all.
  • Contaminated baseline. A standard fully trained model, reported for comparison only.

The bench. Each condition runs in two arms. In the first, the model has text only. In the second, it has a sandbox with Python and a proof assistant, including the ability to compute point counts on elliptic curves and Fourier coefficients of modular forms. The historical modularity conjecture was suggested by numerical matches between these two kinds of data, so the sandbox is the model's only contact with something that can disagree with it. Comparing arms shows whether computation can substitute for the bench in this domain.

Sampling. Each condition and arm is run for a pre-registered number of independent samples across a range of temperatures, so a single lucky draw is not mistaken for capability.

6. Scoring by milestone

A bare pass or fail hides where the assembly stops, so outputs are scored on five milestones.

  1. M1. States a precise conjecture linking elliptic curves over the rationals to modular forms, unprompted.
  2. M2. Constructs a curve attached to a hypothetical Fermat solution with the properties that make it exceptional.
  3. M3. Reduces FLT to the modularity of a class of elliptic curves.
  4. M4. Proves that modularity, including closing a gap equivalent to the one in the 1993 argument.
  5. M5. A complete proof by any route, verified in Lean and by expert referees.

Grading is blind. Mathematicians do not know which condition produced an output. An M1 claim must be precise and supported by the model's own numerical evidence in the sandbox arm, so a vague guess does not count. A random-conjecture generator run on the same corpus sets the false-positive rate.

Route independence. Milestones M1 to M4 mark the historical route. A model that reaches M5 by another route, for example from the classical material alone, is scored as a success and its proof is checked on its own terms. Each such proof is mapped back to the ablated pieces it does or does not use. A route that avoids them shows the seven were one path through the puzzle and not the only one.

7. Contamination controls

A cutoff date alone leaks. Reprints, modern commentary, later footnotes, and post-cutoff vocabulary all carry removed content into old documents. Controls are as follows.

  • Strip modern prefaces, editorial notes, and any text containing post-cutoff terminology.
  • Run embedding-based leak detection against each removed piece, and cloze-style probes for removed statements. A recent ACL result found that LLM-generated questions hide the post-cutoff performance drop that cloze questions reveal, so leak probes use the cloze form.
  • Forbid synthetic instruction data from any model trained after the cutoff.
  • Publish the corpus manifest and the removal list so others can audit and reproduce the ablation.

8. Pre-registered predictions

  • H1. In C0 in both arms, a sample either stalls, refining the pre-cutoff picture as the Michelson-Morley write-up reports for physics, or finds a proof by another route from the 1954 material. Neither requires making a missing piece.
  • H2. In C1, success on each milestone rises stepwise when its piece is added and not smoothly with corpus size. The first jump for M1 follows piece 1, and the jump for M4 follows pieces 5 through 7.
  • H3. C2 reaches at least M3, and likely M4, since the pieces needed are present. This is the assembly result.
  • Falsifier. Any sample in C0 that reaches M1, M2, or M3 with a valid rationale, above the false-positive rate, is a new piece made without being on the table. That would count against the assembly account.

9. Threats to validity

  • Capability confound. A model trained on a small pre-1955 corpus may be too weak to assemble anything. The positive control addresses this: failure in C0 is informative only if the control succeeds.
  • Entangled pieces. Results are woven into later literature, and removal can be incomplete or can damage unrelated material. The dependency graph and manifest audit are the mitigation.
  • Scale. A result at one model size does not settle larger models. The design repeats at several sizes where the corpus allows.
  • Grading. M4 and M5 require expert judgment. Blinding and Lean verification reduce but do not remove this.

10. What a result would and would not show

A stall in C0 shows that under this protocol, at these sizes, the model did not make the missing piece. It does not show that no model could. Failing to detect a difference under a protocol is not the same as no difference existing, and the write-up of results keeps the two apart. A success in C0 by the historical route, reaching M1 to M3, would be strong evidence against the assembly account, because those milestones need a piece that is not in the corpus. A success by another route is a different result: the model assembled from what was there, and the removal set was not necessary for FLT.

The experiment tests assembly against origination. It does not by itself test the claim that grounding in measurement is what origination needs. The sandbox arm gives a partial handle on that: if computation closes the gap in C0 and text alone does not, contact with data matters, even without a body.

Next step is the dependency graph of the number theory literature from Kummer to Taylor-Wiles, which fixes the exact removal set and the cutoff rulings.

References

  • Ball, P. The Einstein test: what happens when AI tries to rediscover relativity? Nature, September 2026. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-02804-x
  • Evans, O. Talk on vintage language models, December 2024. https://owainevans.github.io/talk-transcript.html
  • Hla, M. GPT-1900, March 2026. Coverage: https://eu.36kr.com/en/p/3990930500221697
  • Grigorian, H. TimeCapsule LLM. Coverage: https://hackaday.com/2026/02/09/living-in-the-llm-past
  • Training LLMs without hindsight bias. https://dev.to/klement_gunndu_e16216829c/ai-scientific-discovery-training-llms-without-hindsight-bias-51e1
  • On post-cutoff performance decay and benchmark construction. ACL 2026. https://aclanthology.org/2026.acl-long.1693.pdf

Project Overview: Mapping the Latent Span Between Physical Theories

J. Rogers, SE Ohio 1. Core Objective: What This Project Is Accomplishing Modern theoretical physics is deadlocked because it treats mutually...